Smart People
Monday, April 28th, 2008Not surprisingly, the titular smart people of this movie aren’t so smart. Or to be more accurate, they’re smart about some things (Victorian literature and whatever you need to know to get a perfect SAT score), and incredibly dumb about just about everything else, especially how to get along with other people. What is surprising, and disappointing, is that they are also not very interesting. Dennis Quaid plays Lawrence, a curmudgeonly professor at Carnegie Mellon desperately trying to get his book published and just as desperately trying to become head of his department, even though he dislikes everyone else in it. Ellen Page plays Vanessa, his 17-year-old daughter who has learned how to be a pompous ass intellectual from her father. Her mother is dead, and her brother is at college and is the token normal person in the family. An accident in the opening act sets up Lawrence with Janet, a young doctor (Sarah Jessica Parker) and brings his “adoptive brother” Chuck into the household. Thomas Hayden Church brings the only funny moments with his deadpan observations, but they are scattered too thinly throughout the movie. Quaid plays the grump so convincingly that it is hard to believe Janet’s interest in him. She was a student of his long ago, so perhaps she remembers a kinder, gentler Lawrence. But no, we are told that he was just as pompous then as now and was even responsible for making her change her major from English to Biology. That obviously worked out for her, but as Chuck points out, “if you tell someone they’re stupid they’re probably going to hate you.” Lawrence spends his life telling everyone but Vanessa exactly that. Vanessa is a high-strung overachiever who doesn’t know how to have fun. Chuck tries to show her, triggering another bizarre and unbelievable relationship. I wanted to like this movie and found much to like about it. The performances are solid, and I was rooting for Lawrence and Vanessa to turn their lives around. But the script is thin and the pace slow. Interesting conversations are begun and then abandoned, giving the movie an incomplete feel.